[Termtools] Naive comments from an occasional visitor

Frederic Blanqui frederic.blanqui at inria.fr
Tue Nov 11 03:23:20 CET 2008



Johannes Waldmann a écrit :

>> occasional visitor of the competition site, I would really expect that 
>> Cime3 column should be hidden since results are unreliable.
> 
> Yes. Committee, please answer this:
> should we allow  withdrawal of implemenations:
> http://lists.lri.fr/pipermail/termtools/2008-November/000650.html

What does "withdrawal" mean exactly? If I understand well, Claude only 
suggests that the results of a buggy tool are hidden but the fact that 
the tool tried to participate to the competition must be preserved. 
Indeed, imagine that in a category, only two tools participate and one 
is buggy. If you do not keep the fact that there were two tools in this 
category, the competition makes no sense. Furthermore, I think that such 
a rule should encourage people to do certification.


More information about the Termtools mailing list